Lance Community Voting Process¶
Lance uses a consensus-based voting process for decision-making.
Expressing Votes¶
Votes are expressed as the following:
- +1: Yes
- 0: Abstain
- -1: No
When voting, it is recommended that voters indicate whether their vote is binding or not (e.g., +1 (non-binding), -1 (binding))
to ease the counting of binding votes.
In addition to the vote, voters can also express their justification as part of the comment. -1 votes must include justification to allow meaningful discussion. Any -1 vote not accompanied by justification is considered invalid.
For votes conducted on GitHub Discussions, each vote should be cast as an independent comment instead of as a reply within a comment. This ensures that people can discuss the vote as replies to that specific comment if needed (e.g., to discuss -1 vetoes or address concerns).
Binding Votes¶
Only votes from the binding voters are counted for each decision, but other people in the community are also encouraged to cast non-binding votes. Binding voters should consider any concern from non-binding voters during the vote process.
Vetoes¶
A -1 binding vote is considered a veto for all decision types. Vetoes:
- Stop the proposal until the concerns are resolved
- Cannot be overruled
- Trigger consensus gathering to address concerns
Voting Requirements¶
| Decision Type | +1 Votes Required | Binding Voters | Location | Minimum Period |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Governance process and structure modifications | 3 | PMC | Private Mailing List | 1 week |
| Changes in maintainers and PMC rosters | 3 (excluding the people proposed for change) | PMC | Private Mailing List | 1 week |
| Subproject creation and management | 3 | PMC | GitHub Discussions | 3 days |
| Subproject graduation to core project | 3 | PMC | GitHub Discussions | 1 week |
| Release a new stable major version of core projects | 3 | PMC | GitHub Discussions | 1 week |
| Release a new stable minor version of core projects | 3 | PMC | GitHub Discussions | 3 days |
| Release a new stable patch version of core projects | 3 | PMC | GitHub Discussions | N/A |
| Lance Format Specification modifications | 3 (excluding proposer) | PMC | GitHub Discussions (with a GitHub PR) | 1 week |
| Code modifications in core projects (except changes to format specifications) | 1 (excluding proposer) | Maintainers with write access | GitHub PR | N/A |
| Release a new stable version of subprojects | 1 | PMC | GitHub Discussions | N/A |
| Code modifications in subprojects | 1 (excluding proposer) | Contributors with write access | GitHub PR | N/A |